05302013 - News Article - Former sheriff wants Portage mayor to apologize for police call



Former sheriff wants Portage mayor to apologize for police call
NWI Times
May 30, 2013
http://www.nwitimes.com/business/transportation/former-sheriff-wants-portage-mayor-to-apologize-for-policecall/article_c925daab-1323-58a3-94ea-88c49d365a02.html
Former Lake County Sheriff Roy Dominguez is calling on Portage Mayor James Snyder to apologize for calling police when half a dozen people with disabilities showed up May 23 at a Northwestern Indiana Regional Planning Commission meeting.

"Using that kind of intimidation to discourage people from expressing their concerns in a public setting was downright un-American, and completely uncalled for," Dominguez states in his May 29 letter to Snyder.

Dominguez pointed out among the half a dozen people who came to participate in the NIRPC meeting, three were in wheelchairs and one is blind. Almost all were older, with one being 84. The former sheriff wrote on behalf of the disability rights group Everybody Counts, where he is a board member.

When contacted Thursday, Mayor Snyder said he had not seen Dominguez's letter. When a copy was e-mailed to him he responded that he had no intention of responding to the letter, stating the City of Portage never commented on how Dominguez ran the sheriff's department.

"We have a police presence at all City Council meetings (as do most municipalities) as a preventative safety measure," Snyder stated in his email. "NIRPC has dozens of leaders: mayors, commissioners, councilpeople and state legislators all in one facility, all at one time, and all in one place. The people of Portage have elected me to make decisions to keep them safe from harm and to take preventative measures when necessary as well."

The small group of people had shown up at the NIRPC meeting to hear about and comment on a public participation plan that was scheduled for a vote that day. Some carried signs protesting the proposed plan. Those people waited in the front foyer of NIRPC headquarters for three hours under the watchful eyes of three Portage police officers before being admitted to the NIRPC meeting around noon.

In all, six officers rotated in and out of NIRPC headquarters during the day, with at least three always stationed there.

The long wait was due mainly to confusion over the meeting start time. That came about in part because of an email sent by NIRPC to the disability rights group Everybody Counts stating the meeting would start at the regular time of 9 a.m. The meeting time was subsequently changed to 11 a.m. so a closed session could take place at 9 a.m. to consider lease proposals for NIRPC's headquarters. A notice was posted and sent out about the change.

However, many people, including Hammond Mayor Thomas McDermott Jr., Indiana Department of Transportation Deputy Commissioner Bob Alderman and others showed up expecting the open meeting to start at 9 a.m.

Just after 9 a.m., with members of the public gathered in the meeting room, NIRPC Chairman and Crown Point Mayor David Uran apologized for the confusion and asked the public to leave so the closed session could be conducted. After receiving assurances they would be heard later, all members of the public exited the room.

A few minutes later the police officers showed up.

When the public was readmitted to the meeting room after noon, East Chicago Mayor Anthony Copeland made the motion to postpone the vote on the public participation plan due to what he said were valid concerns brought forth by the advocacy group Everybody Counts. A number of the people who were there are members of the group.

When contacted Thursday, NIRPC Executive Director Ty Warner said he was not aware if that meeting had yet been scheduled yet. He affirmed the meeting will be held.

05232013 - News Article - NIRPC public participation vote postponed



NIRPC public participation vote postponed
NWI Times
May 23, 2013
http://www.nwitimes.com/business/local/nirpc-public-participation-vote-postponed/article_806aa8fe-f4a0-5eb5-a111-bd308c88e110.html
Action on a public participation plan was postponed Thursday at the Northwestern Indiana Regional Planning Commission due to concerns raised by disability rights advocates and confusion over what was to be voted on.

East Chicago Mayor Anthony Copeland made the motion to postpone the vote due to what he said were valid concerns brought forth by the advocacy group Everybody Counts.

"All of your concerns are totally legitimate," Copeland said, as about half a dozen people in the audience held up signs with messages such as "Listen to Us!" and "Liar Liar Plans on Fire!"

The NIRPC board resolved to host a commission meeting specifically devoted to the public participation plan, which has been in the making since last year. Everybody Counts and other disability rights groups have complained their views on the plans have been misrepresented.

NIRPC's public participation plan is designed to meet federal requirements the public have a vigorous voice in NIRPC's actions, such as approving millions of dollars for road projects, regional planning and economic development.

The disability rights advocates had waited for almost three hours for the meeting to begin, after confusion about a closed executive session scheduled for 9 a.m., which is usually when the open full commission meeting takes place.

NIRPC officials produced meeting notices that cited the section of Indiana's Open Meetings law authorizing the closed session and giving its time as 9 a.m.

However, not only the disability-rights advocates, but others such as Hammond Mayor Thomas McDermott Jr. and Indiana Department of Transportation Deputy Commissioner Bob Alderman arrived under the impression the open meeting began at 9 a.m. Alderman waited patiently outside for the closed session to end but had to run to another appointment before the open meeting started.

People at the open meeting also expressed concern about the presence of three Portage police officers, who arrived after being requested by Portage Mayor James Snyder.

Leonard Sullivan, of Chesterton, said he had been coming to NIRPC meetings for more than 40 years and had never seen anything like it. Sullivan said he had nothing against the officers, but they didn't need to be there unless they anticipated a riot.

Snyder said it was standard procedure at some public meetings, including the Portage City Council meetings, especially when people came holding signs.

08132023 - News Article - Former Portage Mayor James Snyder asks US Supreme Court to consider his case

  Former Portage Mayor James Snyder asks US Supreme Court to consider his case Chicago Tribune  Aug 13, 2023 https://www.chicagotribune.com/...